Posted by

I'm a writer/film theorist. Check out my articles on Pixar, Harry Potter, Back to the Future, Die Hard, politics, and more!

As some of you may know, the first article that I ever put out on Creators was "The Pixar Theory by Jon Negroni", and now, with my time at Creators coming to a close, I thought it would be a good idea to talk once again about the Pixar Theory.

In case you don't already know, the Pixar Theory is a theory that explains how every Pixar feature-length film takes place in the same universe, and it's just a long story arc told out of chronological order. Recently, YouTuber Seamus Gorman put out an interesting video:

He talked about how if the Pixar short films took place in the same universe as the feature-length films, it would just create a lot of problems that we don't want to have to deal with.

But I'm gonna break this down piece-by-piece. I'm gonna go through every single Pixar short film since 1986, and I'm gonna talk about how they do or don't fit into the Pixar Theory.

For a clear version of the Pixar Theory, click here.

The Adventures of André and Wally B.

Now, this was made way back in 1984, before Pixar was even named Pixar. So, that's why the animation isn't as good as it is now. But in this film, Wally B. is a bee, and André is, according to the Pixar Wiki, a "boy-like character". This was back when they couldn't really animate humans that well, so I'll assume that André is a human.

If I had to guess, the bumblebee is interested in André the human, the way Remy was interested in human culture. Wally is interested in the human and he follows him, learning about the culture of humans, which was a big part of the Pixar Theory.

Luxo, Jr.

In the Pixar Theory, BnL gives life to toys, and they come to life. Well, in this short film, we have two alive lamps, and a ball. BnL gives life to these lamps the way toys are given life. I mean, come on; if an Etch-A-Sketch can be alive in Toy Story, why can't a desk lamp?

We also know that these things exist in the Pixar universe. The ball in the short film has been in a lot of the Pixar films.

And a red version of the exact same lamp appears in Andy's bedroom.

Red's Dream

Like with Luxo, Jr., BnL has given enough energy to inanimate objects for them to essentially come to life and have their own human-like emotions. Red also has the ability to have dreams, the way Woody had a nightmare in Toy Story 2.

Tin Toy

Again, BnL has given toys energy to come to life, the exact same principle from Toy Story. And some of the toys in Billy's room appear again in Toy Story 3, once again hiding from destructive children.

Knick Knack

Once again, it's living toys brought to life by energy from BnL.

But here's a quick fun fact: if you're below the age of 12, just keep scrolling down to the next short film, and don't stop. But if you're 12 and over, here's a cool fact for you:

In the original short film, the Sunny Miami's breasts were HUGE. They were literally gigantic. And when the film was re-released years later and digitally remastered, the breasts were shrunk by a lot.

Geri's Game

This is a pretty nice little link to the Pixar films. The old man, Geri, in this short film is the same man who cleans Woody in Toy Story 2.

For The Birds

The birds you see in this short film later appear in the same formation in Inside Out.

Boundin'

You remember how in the Pixar Theory, there were years when animals were being mistreated by humans? With all the fishing in Finding Nemo, and we saw how desperate Hank was to get away from humans in Finding Dory.

In this short film, we have a small lamb who gets sheared. Although it is for his own good, the lamb feels a lot of resentment toward humans the same way Hank does and all the animals who don't like human culture, including Remy's dad in Ratatouille.

One Man Band

Well, I thought I was doing pretty good with myself up till this one. Since it's just three humans, there's no evidence of any link to the Pixar Theory involving humans, animals, or artificial intelligence. But there's no evidence that goes AGAINST this short film fitting into the Pixar Theory.

If you have any ideas about this, tell me in the comments.

Lifted

We know that it exists in the same universe as Tin Toy, because Tin Toy exists, since we see the toy beneath Ernie's bed.

Also, Ernie the farmer looks a lot like Alfredo Linguini from Ratatouille. They're definitely not the same person because of the name and profession, but Ernie and Alfredo could definitely be related. Brothers? Father and son?

Presto

There is a lot of animal-human interaction in this short film, but I don't see how it would tie into the Pixar Theory. However, according to the Pixar Wiki, the theater where this short takes place is the same theater where Charles Muntz introduces the skeleton in Up, and a waiter from Ratatouille is one of the performing musicians.

On a side note, this is the corniest freaking magician I have ever seen in my life. No modern magician looks or acts like this and no magician in their right mind would pull a rabbit out of a hat without the specific intent of showing the stereotype.

Partly Cloudy

Okay, this is the only short film so far to go AGAINST the Pixar Theory. In Pixar movies like Up and Inside Out, they made it at least subtly clear that you came out of your mom's vagina, and not from a cloud creating babies and giving them to storks.

So, I hate to say it, but Partly Cloudy doesn't fit in with the Pixar movies.

Day & Night

Well, I don't really know about this one...it's not really something that can be dissected. Does it fit into the Pixar Theory? I don't know. The point is, what the hell are those things anyway?

The lumberjack that's chopping down a tree is Tom from Up, but is he real or is he just a visual in whatever the hell these things are. What the hell is this supposed to BE?

La Luna

Aw, no. I don't know about this one. I don't know how it possibly ties into the theory, and I don't really know what this is. Dammit.

The Blue Umbrella

I was a little too distracted by the fact that the animation in this short film was phenomenal, but maybe BnL has given life to objects that aren't just toys, and can make almost anything anthropomorphic. I don't know. That's just my hypothesis.

Lava

How the hell do volcanoes come to life? I mean, come on. It's a nice story, it's a nice song, but I can't solve this.

Sanjay's Super Team

DAMN IT, PIXAR. THIS WAS SO EASY IN THE BEGINNING. THERE AREN'T EVEN ANY EASTER EGGS OR ANYTHING IN THIS.

Piper

Well, the birds and crabs in this short have human-like qualities, as seen in Ratatouille, but I don't know if this is how they act in real life.

Lou

To my knowledge, the bully in this short film grows up to be in Riley's class in Inside Out.

And that's it!

If you have ideas for the shorts that DON'T fit into the Pixar Theory, let me know in the comments below.

Latest from our Creators